Amnesia is pretty spooks (the first one at least). Heard A Machine for Chumps was weak since thechineseroom (Devs of Dear Ester) did the development instead of Irrational.
Dead Space was pretty nifty since i think i recall playing it after Resident Evil 5 (which was pretty meh in scares) and the Condemned games were cool (especially 2: Bloodshot up until the final mission, where shit got stupid).
Another neato game actually came out recently. It was a fangame for the Movie "Halloween" by an independent game developer called
Pig Farmer Games. It had inspirations from old school PSX games like "Silent Hill" and "Resident Evil" graphics wise and how you can have fixed camera angles.
I use past tense words like "WAS" and "HAD" because it unfortunately got removed because the developer was told to remove it and it's not up for grabs anymore...
BUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUT I WAS LUCKY ENOUGH TO GET IT BEFORE IT WAS REMOVED. IF YOU WANT TO DOWNLOAD IT,
CLICK HERE YOU CUNTIES